
Halloween rolls around every October and with it a childhood memory from growing up in post-World War II suburbia—in my case, a rapidly expanding neighborhood in what we now call Haymount. It was teeming with young Baby Boomers and dogs, and we all ran around together in packs. One Halloween, for reasons I do not know and can no longer ask, our parents allowed my sister and me to go trick-or-treating alone.
Granted, it was only on our own short street and it was still daylight, but we were young enough that she does not remember this story. It made a huge impression on me, though. Carrying our brown paper grocery sacks decorated with crayon-drawn witches and black cats, we made our way alone down the other side of our street where we knew most everyone, but not all.
We knocked on the door of a house we had never visited, and a smiling woman opened the door and exclaimed, “You are lucky little girls. You are getting the last two!!” My mind immediately jumped to “last two what?” Hershey bars? Snickers? Sugar Daddys?
She was back in a jiffy and quickly plopped a small kitten and a can of cat food into each of our bags, and firmly closed her door.
We were thrilled!
Not so our parents or the hunting dog, a Weimaraner, our only pet, who went into immediate pointing and tracking mode the moment he whiffed the kitties.
Suffice it to say there were few “helicopter parents” for Baby Boomer kiddos.
Our parents were apparently early versions of what we now call “free range parents,” what AI defines as parents who encourage children “to develop independence, confidence, and self-reliance through age-appropriate freedom and limited direct adult supervision.”
I doubt our parents or others in our young-family neighborhood had any idea that was what they were doing, letting us loose on our own for hours at a time. Blessedly, we all survived, as will most of the children with today’s version of free range parents, all of whom hope to raise thoughtful, independent and self-confident adults.
But free range parenting is not without its critics, and with good reason.
Last month, a mother who left her 4 children aged 9 to 14 home alone, while she went on a business trip was arrested in Florida. Dad was not in the home, and mom hired a babysitter to get them to and from school, and they did fine otherwise until a dumbbell somehow fell on the 9-year-old’s head and he had to go to the hospital. Mom was arrested and jailed on 4 counts of child neglect.
This renewed a national debate over what constitutes thoughtful but hands-off parenting and what constitutes smothering one’s offspring’s independence. Enough Americans apparently believe that modern parenting, with what the New York Times calls its “ultra-watchful standard of modern American childrearing,” is detrimental and has resulted in 13 states, including Florida, where the dumbbell victim and his siblings live, to enact childhood independence laws.
Looking back over my childrearing days, I think my family tried to have it both ways. My husband and I did not leave our children alone for days, nor did we let them escape from activities we thought they should explore, like sports, the theater, various kinds of lessons. Overall, though, I think we tended more toward the laissez faire position, as this story illustrates.
I was chatting with our next-door neighbor, herself one of 4 children, the mother of 3 boys, and a kindergarten teacher. In other words, she knew a lot more about the thinking of young children than I did.
Said Margaret, “The children are in the back yard playing.”
Said Jane, laughing, “No, the children are in the back yard smoking.”
I knew where they were but was clueless about what they were doing.
LOL!