NC Schools: The Sad, Hard Truth About Leandro
- Details
- Tuesday, 14 April 2026
- Written by Margaret Dickson
Robb Leandro is disappointed.
Robb was a Hoke County eighth grader when a major lawsuit regarding public education was filed with his name as the lead plaintiff. The original 1994 case challenged North Carolina’s school funding formula on behalf of young Robb and students in 5 low-wealth counties, including Cumberland, Hoke, Vance, Halifax, and Robeson. At issue was—and is—whether North Carolina children are entitled to “a sound, basic education” as described in our state Constitution. Over time, the case has come to involve early childhood education, high quality educators, and accountability issues.
Our North Carolina Supreme Court has just ruled that none of these educational components are required by our Constitution and dismissed the long-running lawsuit despite the reality that other courts have made radically different decisions.
Today, almost 32 years later, Robb Leandro is a Raleigh attorney specializing in health care issues. His epic lawsuit may have met its end, a victim of this century’s toxic politics. The Supreme Court’s death blow was dealt by 4 Republicans intent on privatizing public education. Dissenting were 2 Democrats and 1 Republican who bucked their party to support public education.
The original issue at its most elemental level was—and remains—that North Carolina children who live in wealthier counties, like Wake and Mecklenburg that can afford higher school spending, are likely to receive a more comprehensive public education than children in counties that have fewer resources. The suit asked: Could young Robb, living in low-wealth Hoke County, receive the same quality education as another Robb growing up in Wake County? For decades, various courts ruled that he could not and ordered the state to beef up educational spending. Those decisions have been appealed at every turn, so back to the courts the Leandro case has gone time and time again.
That remains the basic issue, but over the years, the case has also become burdened with partisan political questions involving division of powers among the 3 branches of government: legislative, executive, and judicial.
Layered upon all this, the North Carolina General Assembly has begun channeling billions of state tax dollars into private schools with very little accountability and leaving public schools ever more starved for funding. As students follow state dollars to private schools and make other choices, including homeschooling, public school rolls are decreasing, meaning even fewer state dollars coming in. School closures loom in a growing number of communities, including Cumberland County.
Many people think of this situation as a deliberate abandonment of public education. Some would even say it is a war against public schools now well on its way to the half-century mark.
Governor Stein voiced his version of a war cry regarding the court’s decision this way.
“Education opens doors of opportunity for children, but today the Court slammed them in the face of students who deserve the right to a sound, public education. The Supreme Court simply ignored its own established precedent, enabling the General Assembly to deprive another generation of North Carolina students of the educational opportunity promised by our Constitution.”
I wonder whether the 4 North Carolina Supreme Court Justices who slammed that door on North Carolina’s young people wonder what several generations could have accomplished, invented, created had they had access to top notch public schools. If they wonder, do they care? Do they believe quality public education is for only who can afford it or that quality public education floats all boats and enriches community life in North Carolina?
They seem to have answered those questions earlier this month.
How to resolve AdBlock issue?