We know you just took down the Christmas tree and swept up the confetti from New Year's, but believe it or not, Valentine’s Day is right around the corner. Valentine’s Day has a way of sneaking up on us, and suddenly the pressure is on to find the perfect place for that perfect night. Whether you’re planning a candlelit dinner, a cozy casual date, or something with a little small‑town charm, our local area has a surprisingly rich mix of options.
This guide brings together some of the most loved, most atmospheric, and most date‑worthy restaurants across Fayetteville, Hope Mills, Spring Lake, and Raeford — so you can focus on the fun part: enjoying the night with someone special.

Fayetteville

Luigi’s Italian Chophouse & Bar, 528 N McPherson Church Rd.
910-864-1810
If your idea of romance includes dim lighting, a glass of wine, and the aroma of garlic and herbs drifting through the air, Luigi’s is your spot. This long‑time local favorite blends Italian comfort with steakhouse sophistication. It’s warm, intimate, and perfect for couples who want a traditional Valentine’s experience. https://luigischophouse.com/

Chris’s Steak & Seafood House, 2620 Raeford Rd.
910-485-4242
For those who love a more upscale evening, Chris’s delivers. Think rich wood interiors, expertly prepared steaks, and a timeless atmosphere that feels made for special occasions. It’s the kind of place where you linger over dessert because the night feels too good to rush. https://www.fayettevillesteakhouse.com/

Scruboaks Contemporary American Pub, 5780 Ramsey St., Suite 108
910-884-3072
Fresh, thoughtful, and full of character, ScrubOaks Contemporary American Pub offers a cozy setting that works beautifully for a relaxed Valentine’s Day dinner.
The menu shifts with the seasons, highlighting quality ingredients and dishes made to order, giving every plate a just‑for‑you feel. Portions are generous, flavors are comforting, and the atmosphere strikes that easy balance between casual and special — perfect for couples who want a laid‑back but memorable night out. https://www.scruboakspub.com/

Antonella's Italian Ristorante, 300 Hay St.
910-486-0046
If you are looking for an elegant dining establishment located in the heart of Downtown Fayetteville, this is the place. Treat yourself and your special someone to classic Italian dishes, fresh seafood specialties, and even vegan options. Don't forget to complement your meal with a crafted signature cocktail. https://www.antonellasitalianristorante.com/

Spring Lake

La Vista Italian Restaurant, 1107 N. Bragg Blvd., Spring Lake
910-229-3588
Warm, comforting, and full of charm, La Vista Italian Restaurant brings classic Italian flavors to a cozy Spring Lake setting.
It’s a great pick for couples who want something delicious without the fuss of a formal night out. The dishes are hearty, the portions generous, and the atmosphere relaxed with just the right touch of romance. https://www.lavistaitaliannc.com/

Sawaddee Thai & Chinese Restaurant, 1006 N. Bragg Blvd., Spring Lake
910-436-5757
Vibrant and full of flavor, Sawaddee Thai & Chinese Restaurant offers a cozy spot for couples looking to enjoy something a little different on Valentine’s Day.
This family‑run favorite serves generous portions of comforting Thai classics, from fragrant curries to perfectly seasoned stir‑fried dishes. The atmosphere is relaxed yet inviting, making it easy to linger and enjoy the moment. And for a sweet finish, their homemade desserts add just the right touch of indulgence to a romantic meal. https://tinyurl.com/cr4a3b2e

Hope Mills

Sammio's Italian Restaurant, 3057 N. Main St., Hope Mills
910-424-4000
Comforting, classic, and easy to love, Sammio’s Italian Restaurant delivers a warm setting that suits a relaxed Valentine’s Day dinner. The menu is filled with familiar favorites, ranging from pasta and pizza to hearty chicken, steak, and seafood dishes, all served in generous portions that make sharing effortless.
The atmosphere is welcoming yet informal, providing couples with a cozy space to unwind and enjoy a satisfying meal together. https://www.sammiositalianrestaurant.com/

Raeford

The Creekside Mill, 1825 Johnson Mill Rd., Raeford
910-878-2376
Rustic, inviting, and beloved by locals, The Creekside Mill is a great pick for couples who want a casual but memorable night out. The menu is hearty, the service friendly, and the vibe just right for a low‑key Valentine’s dinner. .https://thecreeksidemill.com/

No matter what kind of Valentine’s Day you’re planning — elegant, cozy, adventurous, or delightfully simple — you will find a restaurant that fits the moment. From Fayetteville’s romantic classics to Raeford’s small‑town gems, you’re never far from a memorable meal.