As North Carolina continues to emerge as a major hub for technology infrastructure, the debate over data centers has arrived in Fayetteville and Cumberland   County. These massive digital facilities—quiet, high security homes for the servers that power banking, retail, communications, and entertainment—are expanding rapidly across our state.

With interest percolating here in Cumberland County, residents and community leaders are asking an important question: Do data centers represent a smart long term investment for Cumberland County, or do they come with trade offs that outweigh the benefits?

This is an important quality of life issue, so we have put together a simple, easy-to-read side by side comparison of the key advantages and disadvantages, tailored to the priorities of our community.

Economic Impact: Investment vs. Jobs

PRO: Major Capital Investment & Tax Base Growth

Data centers bring enormous upfront investment—often hundreds of millions of dollars. Even with incentives, they add substantial taxable value that can support schools, public safety, and infrastructure.

Construction generates a surge of economic activity, employing local contractors, engineers, and tradespeople.

CON: Limited Permanent Job Creation

Once built, data centers employ relatively few people—typically 20 to 50 full time staff.

For a county focused on workforce development and upward mobility, some argue that other industries may offer a better long term return in job creation.

Local Infrastructure Improvements: Upgrades vs. Strain

PRO: Upgrading Community Wide Infrastructure 

To support data centers, counties often receive improvements to:

• Power grids

• Water and sewer systems

• Broadband capacity

• Road access

These upgrades strengthen the county’s overall infrastructure and can accelerate broader economic development.

CON: Enormous Energy Consumption

A single data center can consume as much electricity as a small town.

Local residents have concerns that include:

• A strain on the electrical grid

• Need for new substations or transmission lines

• Potential PWC rate increases

• Whether industrial demand limits future growth

Energy capacity is already a sensitive issue in many communities in North Carolina.

Economic Diversification: Stability vs. Resource Allocation

PRO: Diversifying Cumberland County’s Economy

Data centers will help broaden Cumberland County’s economy, which has long been anchored by the military, healthcare, education and small business. Some signal that the county is ready for modern, high tech investment and can help stabilize the local economy during downturns.

CON: Large Land Requirements

Data centers often require 50 to 200 acres of well located land. Once built, they occupy that land for decades while providing relatively few jobs. Some argue that mixed use development, housing, or light manufacturing could generate more community benefit per acre.

Community Impact: Low Impact Neighbors vs. Environmental Concerns

PRO: Quiet, Low Impact Industrial Use

Data centers in general produce minimal noise, generate little traffic, operate quietly 24/7, and do not emit pollutants. For residents concerned about preserving neighborhood character, data centers are among the least disruptive industrial uses.

CON: Water Usage & Environmental Questions

It is well known that data centers use significant amounts of water for cooling, especially in summer.

While Cumberland County’s water supply is stable, large industrial users can strain long term capacity and raise environmental concerns for neighborhoods, agriculture, and future growth. 

Local Business Ecosystem: Opportunity vs. Incentive Concerns

PRO: Support for Local Tech & Service Businesses

Data centers attract an ecosystem of supporting industries:

• Cybersecurity firms

• Fiber optic and networking companies

• HVAC and electrical specialists

• Backup power and battery suppliers

This can create new opportunities for local businesses already serving Fort Bragg and the region’s tech needs.

CON: Public Skepticism Over Incentives

To attract data centers, counties often offer tax incentives.

Cumberland County residents want transparency and assurance that these incentives don’t shortchange schools or public services, and that the long term benefits outweigh the concessions. County residents need assurance that the county isn’t giving away too much for too little return

Well, without a doubt, this will be a decision that will shape Fayetteville and Cumberland County’s growth in the future. Data centers offer real advantages—investment, infrastructure, diversification, and low impact operation. But they also raise valid concerns about energy use, land allocation, water resources, and public incentives. As Cumberland County continues to grow, the community must consider:

• What kind of growth do we want?

• How should we allocate land, water, and energy?

• What mix of industries best supports long term prosperity?

The North Carolina General Assembly is currently advancing Senate Bill 730 (the Ratepayer Protection Act), which would regulate large data centers. Earlier this month, the House voted to approve the bill. It now awaits the Senate's approval. This bill addresses most of the concerns mentioned earlier in this article. So while the state legislature finishes debating the bill, Fayetteville and other municipalities and counties across North Carolina have enacted temporary local moratoriums on data center construction.   

Data centers are reshaping North Carolina’s economic landscape. Whether they become part of Cumberland County’s future will depend on how well our local leadership evaluates the benefits and how well they align with the values and vision of the people who call Cumberland County home. 

Thank you for reading Up & Coming Weekly.